تحقيقات

THE CASE OF THE DOUMA4 ACTIVISTS…CONVENIENTLY OVERLOOKING THE EVIDENCE

Written on 11 November 2014 by Osama Nassar

It is now almost a year in darkness for the Douma four kidnapped activists.

Almost a year ago activist and ex-political prisoner Samira al-Khalil, Lawyer and human rights defender Razan Zaitouneh, her husband, Engineer and activist Wael Hamadeh, and Lawyer and Poet Nazem Al Hamadi, went missing in Douma.

Although it’s common knowledge that the four activists are veteran opponents to the Assad regime who without doubt is the Godfather of criminals in the country, however, in this case Assad was surprisingly not the perpetrator, it was an assumed “ally”. Despite the contradiction in categorizing this criminal as an ally, it’s the undeniable way of describing the case of the four kidnapped activists who had sought sanctuary in the “liberated” Ghouta after they all became wanted by the regime’s security apparatus due to their activism in support of the revolution and revolutionaries.

The fate of the four activists and the identity of their kidnapper are yet to be determined.

It is undoubtedly a complicated case, particularly because the perpetrator had the opportunity to contemplate the crime and cover up the evidence.

Nevertheless, those who are working on uncovering the circumstances and facts of the kidnapping incident have revealed key evidence, three of which are explained in this article.

First evidence: Statements vs. Facts

The kidnapping incident which took place on the night of Tuesday the 9th of December 2013 was only discovered the following morning. On the 15th of December, representatives of the main insurgent groups in Eastern Ghouta met at the headquarters of the Mujahideen Council and issued a statement under oath, denying any involvement in three incidents and stating that they are “unaware of any of them and willing to cooperate and fully support the inquiry”1.

The three incidents being: The kidnapping of Dr. Ahmad Buqaie by persons unknown, the abduction of the four activists, Razan Zaitouneh and her colleagues (as worded in the statement), and the murder of Abou Abdel Rahman al-Khateeb, a member of ISIS, also by persons unknown.

Despite the claim made in the first article of the statement, a month after the statement was issued Dr. Buqaie was released from a prison controlled by al-Nusra Front [Jabhat al-Nusra] who was one of the signatories to the statement. It also came to light that a large part of Dr. Buqaie’s interrogation during his detention revolved around Razan, her husband, his relation with them, and whether he had cooperated with them in any way.

The question now is: Was the statement of innocence by the signatories a perjury? Baring in mind that the handwritten statement was concluded with the following phrase: “This document stands as testament against all its signatories and the falsehood of any claims shall hold the signatories accountable. The inquiry shall continue even amongst the signatory groups, as God is the best of witnesses”.

Perhaps there are religious excuses or fatwas that allow false statements to be made under oath due to one’s own definition of ‘necessity’. However, have those falsehoods been followed up by, or explained to, the assembly of signatories? Doesn’t circumventing one of the statement’s articles suggest that this could have also been the case for the rest?

Statement under oath signed by 14 insurgent groups in Douma dated 15 December 2013

Second evidence: An eyewitness account:

A woman who still resides in an area in Eastern Ghouta has stated that she coincidentally saw Razan inside a prison controlled by an insurgent group that she identified, she also identified and located the prison in which she was held on criminal charges. Credible or not, this woman’s statement should have been investigated. Has such an investigation ever taken place?

Third evidence: Technology determines a geographic location:

Yassin al-Haj Saleh, the husband of Samira al-Khalil and a friend of the other three kidnapped activists, mentioned in his article titled “Nine Months”, published on “The Republic” [al-Jumhuriya] website2, that he has “irrefutable evidence, not speculations” that identify “the kidnappers or the organizers and facilitators of the kidnapping”. We asked him about this evidence, he answered: “I have irrefutable evidence that a named individual, who is a member of the insurgent group called the “Islam Army” [Jaysh al-Islam – led by Zahran Alloush] had accessed the computers of the kidnapped, which were confiscated during their abduction. We also have proof that Facebook accounts belonging to members of “Islam Army” had been created from the same location. When a commander in the Islam Army was informed about this evidence, those accounts were immediately deleted, without any further action”

Answering the same question, a friend of the abductees that had cooperated with Mr. al-Haj Saleh to acquire this information said: “Immediately after we learned of the abduction, we closed the Facebook, Skype and email accounts of the kidnapped activists. These are routine measures that are taken when an activist is arrested by the regime, to prevent their account being forcefully opened and information obtained leading to further harm to them and others. However, three days after the kidnapping we noticed Razan’s Skype account was accessed [online], and the same happened to Wael’s account a little later. Moreover, the Viber accounts of both Razan and Wael showed that they were accessed four days after their abduction.

We informed some technicians about this, who then checked with Microsoft, owner of Skype, and confirmed the incidents and reset the security measures for the abductees accounts”.

Before taking this information to IT security expert, Mr. Basel Matar, we tried to access the raw information directly from its source. One company that owns Internet servers stated that an activity has been detected from the Skype accounts of Razan and Wael via a specific IP address. By tracing that IP address it turned out that Facebook accounts belonging to members of Islam Army had been created through it. Some of those members are well known and present in Eastern Ghouta. Also, Razan and Wael’s Viber accounts have been logged into from this same IP address. The accuracy of information obtained via such process was later confirmed by Mr. Matar.

From there we went to Dr. Kussay Moselmani, lawyer and teacher of International Law and the head of the Syrian European Center for Human Rights, and asked: What is the legal and judicial stance regarding what is referred to as “Geospatial Information and Technology”?

Dr. Kussay answered: “Regarding the admissibility of digital and geospatial evidence: International and Arab legislations on criminal trials and penal codes have agreed to a core principle which is the freedom of proof in penal matters; this principle, explained briefly, means that “Evidence in crimes, felonies and violations are established by all forms of proof”, from witness testimonies to confessions, expertise, observations and evidence. Thus rendering digital and geospatial evidence admissible in principle to prove guilt or innocence, just as is the case with all traditional and conventional means of evidence.

As for validity: digital and geospatial evidence derived from their sources in accordance with the basis of information and digital technology science, presented by a legal expert officially designated by the judge are valid proof to which the latter can resort to base his convictions and rulings for verdicts of innocence or guilt.

Within this framework, international criminal litigation institutions routinely admit such evidence to prove war crimes and crimes against humanity. This was done in 2006, when the International Criminal Court charged the President of Sudan Omar al-Bashir with war crimes and crimes against humanity, in addition to charges of forced displacement. The submitted evidence included satellite images determining the location of some villages in Darfur that were destroyed and burnt down.

Based on that, if the technical expertise enforced by the court proved that those who have accessed the accounts of Razan and Wael are members of the “Islam Army”, it would be considered as evidence of the identity of the perpetrators and their affiliation, which will bring to light the responsibility of the leaders of the insurgent group to which those members belong.

On the responsibility of the military leadership:

Sharia laws conforms with International Humanitarian Law and International Criminal law conventions on the responsibility of the military leaders for violations of International Humanitarian Law rules committed by their subordinates. Article 86 of the first additional protocol issued in 1977, annexed to the Geneva conventions of 1949 has stated that:

1. The High Contracting Parties and the Parties to the conflict shall repress grave breaches, and take measures necessary to suppress all other breaches, of the Conventions or of this Protocol which result from a failure to act when under a duty to do so.

2. 

The fact that a breach of the Conventions or of this Protocol was committed by a subordinate does not absolve his superiors from penal or disciplinary responsibility, as the case may be, if they knew, or had information which should have enabled them to conclude in the circumstances at the time, that he was committing or was going to commit such a breach and if they did not take all feasible measures within their power to prevent or repress the breach.3

Article 28 of the Rome Statute that established the International Criminal Court has also stated a similar denotation.4

From the above we conclude that establishing the responsibility of the military leader requires three basic elements:

1- The existence of a leader-subordinate relationship: That the practice of leadership or control is determined and confirmed.

2- That the higher ranking officer or leader had knowledge, or could have had knowledge, that one or more of his subordinates have committed criminal acts or attempted to do so.

3- That the higher ranking officer abates to deploy necessary and reasonable measures to prevent the commitment of the incriminating aforementioned acts.

Going back to Mr. Yassin al-Haj Saleh, and asking him about the procedures that were taken following the uncovering of this information, he replied:

“When Zahran Alloush was personally informed of the matter, he had nothing to say but “Perhaps there has been some sort of mistake”! This is an unacceptably irresponsible statement, similar to what Syrian regime officials would say when confronted with something embarrassing.”

Agonized by the disappearance of his wife and his friends, al-Haj Saleh continues: “The fate of the four abductees, two women and two men of the bravest and most noble Syrians, one of them is my wife, a political prisoner held by the regime in Douma prison specifically, who came to Ghouta seeking refuge, is not something that can be easily overlooked. I demand that Alloush is held accountable before an independent investigation committee in my presence, and I am prepared for a public debate with him on an independent media channel. In my view, he is the one and only suspect, until he himself, not others, submit what leads to the four activists, and acquits him from the crime.”

Yassin concludes his article Nine Months with an “advice to the kidnappers”:

“Do not underestimate us, we will not fall silent short from justice, the rights that are ours and of our fellow citizens will be upheld at all costs. Do not underestimate our persistence and patience, nor the efficiency of our work methods. Do not assume that we will succumb to extortions or that you can silence us. Only the immediate release of the four abductees can stop the huge damage you have caused us and brought upon our cause, and limit the huge damage that we shall cause you, and we shall not cease to do so.”

Of course when he says “the huge damage that we shall cause you”, Yassin al-Haj Saleh does not mean that we will form an armed militia to launch a counter war on the kidnapping militias, nor will we gather a gang of thugs to abduct family members and friends of those involved in this crime and cause them the same agony they have caused us.

Rather, out of loyalty to the noble abductees themselves, and that of everyone who has fought for justice and truth, we shall work only through legal and ethical methods.

Mr. Yassin adds: “We want the four free now. And as long as they remain absent, we shall work employing various methods to keep the cause of the four alive and unhindered by any statute of limitations, and to frame the kidnappers and keep them in a state of prosecution everywhere.”

He concludes: “Nobody should test our patience, nor our ability to defend ourselves and our loved ones. We have been tried and tested. Those who do not know, should ask the Assad regime who knows us very well.”

 

85 Comments

85 Comments

  1. Wsmccy

    8 يناير,2024 at 11:08 ص

    alternatives to allergy medication 3rd generation antihistamines list claritin allergy sinus 12hr costco

  2. Hkufgc

    15 يناير,2024 at 7:02 ص

    homeopathic medicine for stomach acid purchase duricef online

  3. Ucwqmt

    16 يناير,2024 at 2:48 ص

    accutane drug accutane 10mg pill order accutane 20mg generic

  4. Vzvaju

    18 يناير,2024 at 8:00 ص

    amoxil 250mg price amoxil 500mg over the counter buy amoxil paypal

  5. Rjluue

    18 يناير,2024 at 11:55 ص

    best online rx for sleep purchase provigil online cheap

  6. Lbrwja

    19 يناير,2024 at 9:34 م

    zithromax ca azithromycin 250mg tablet buy zithromax pills for sale

  7. Ylqpba

    20 يناير,2024 at 4:36 ص

    brand gabapentin cheap gabapentin 600mg

  8. Wkmnvj

    21 يناير,2024 at 1:53 م

    purchase azithromycin azithromycin 250mg pills buy azipro 250mg without prescription

  9. Krbtcx

    21 يناير,2024 at 11:05 م

    buy generic lasix for sale furosemide 100mg over the counter

  10. Mbeajc

    23 يناير,2024 at 3:27 ص

    omnacortil 40mg brand buy generic omnacortil prednisolone 40mg over the counter

  11. Ochqap

    25 يناير,2024 at 1:32 م

    buy amoxicillin 500mg online cheap cheap generic amoxil oral amoxicillin 500mg

  12. Cokrvp

    25 يناير,2024 at 7:49 م

    vibra-tabs uk order monodox

  13. Yxxglu

    27 يناير,2024 at 1:54 ص

    purchase albuterol ventolin inhalator cheap albuterol 2mg brand

  14. Oeihgt

    28 يناير,2024 at 12:21 ص

    augmentin 625mg brand generic augmentin 625mg

  15. Jqimlo

    28 يناير,2024 at 11:32 م

    cheap synthroid 100mcg synthroid 100mcg usa buy cheap synthroid

  16. Vsjstd

    29 يناير,2024 at 10:11 ص

    levitra 20mg for sale vardenafil 10mg pills

  17. Iiuwzg

    30 يناير,2024 at 5:04 ص

    where can i buy clomiphene purchase clomid generic clomiphene 100mg uk

  18. Tihttp

    1 فبراير,2024 at 1:08 ص

    rybelsus 14 mg pills semaglutide for sale online cost rybelsus 14mg

  19. Loanbt

    2 فبراير,2024 at 2:29 ص

    buy prednisone 5mg sale prednisone uk order generic deltasone

  20. Xmihbw

    2 فبراير,2024 at 8:03 م

    semaglutide 14mg sale buy rybelsus 14mg order semaglutide for sale

  21. Erwqxk

    3 فبراير,2024 at 4:17 م

    buy absorica without prescription order isotretinoin 40mg pill accutane pill

  22. Hifqrj

    4 فبراير,2024 at 6:39 ص

    albuterol buy online order albuterol 4mg sale albuterol brand

  23. Siiuji

    5 فبراير,2024 at 9:53 ص

    amoxil 250mg oral purchase amoxil pill amoxil without prescription

  24. Euedov

    5 فبراير,2024 at 11:46 م

    purchase augmentin online amoxiclav price buy generic amoxiclav

  25. Afrxhc

    7 فبراير,2024 at 1:28 ص

    order azithromycin 250mg generic buy zithromax 250mg pill buy zithromax online

  26. Itblfx

    7 فبراير,2024 at 3:23 م

    levoxyl price brand levothyroxine levoxyl canada

  27. Vhmnmy

    8 فبراير,2024 at 5:37 م

    omnacortil 5mg oral prednisolone pills prednisolone online buy

  28. Lvjrex

    9 فبراير,2024 at 8:17 ص

    clomid 50mg for sale buy clomid 50mg online buy clomiphene paypal

  29. Aicsgy

    10 فبراير,2024 at 8:15 ص

    gabapentin 100mg over the counter gabapentin 600mg ca buy neurontin 600mg for sale

  30. Jqktrl

    11 فبراير,2024 at 2:59 م

    real viagra pills order viagra pills viagra 50mg over the counter

  31. Nzbfxg

    11 فبراير,2024 at 11:06 م

    buy lasix 100mg pill furosemide pills lasix 40mg oral

  32. Lukqfh

    13 فبراير,2024 at 4:23 ص

    rybelsus 14 mg brand semaglutide pills semaglutide 14mg us

  33. Jpninr

    14 فبراير,2024 at 2:42 م

    vardenafil 20mg without prescription order vardenafil 10mg generic vardenafil 20mg cost

  34. Tbhrrt

    14 فبراير,2024 at 5:31 م

    play online roulette for fun free spins no deposit us play slots

  35. Pfozkn

    16 فبراير,2024 at 1:21 ص

    purchase hydroxychloroquine generic purchase plaquenil for sale order plaquenil sale

  36. Qmtdbk

    16 فبراير,2024 at 1:22 ص

    lyrica 75mg uk buy pregabalin 75mg generic cost pregabalin 150mg

  37. Zvlhhg

    17 فبراير,2024 at 7:46 ص

    how to get aristocort without a prescription triamcinolone cost order triamcinolone 4mg sale

  38. Oaixln

    18 فبراير,2024 at 5:29 م

    buy cenforce generic cenforce price buy cenforce 100mg sale

  39. Xfmywv

    20 فبراير,2024 at 3:12 ص

    chloroquine 250mg usa where to buy chloroquine without a prescription cost aralen

  40. Yqldit

    20 فبراير,2024 at 4:34 ص

    loratadine generic order loratadine generic buy claritin without prescription

  41. Jovvzd

    21 فبراير,2024 at 9:54 ص

    glucophage 1000mg canada brand glycomet 1000mg glycomet where to buy

  42. Fhubtx

    21 فبراير,2024 at 10:17 ص

    dapoxetine 30mg sale dapoxetine 90mg for sale order cytotec for sale

  43. Zjhmfk

    21 فبراير,2024 at 6:20 م

    order metformin 1000mg generic buy glycomet 1000mg pill glycomet 500mg brand

  44. Qnzvmh

    22 فبراير,2024 at 6:54 م

    order orlistat 120mg generic order xenical 120mg generic buy diltiazem 180mg generic

  45. Lkdfdt

    23 فبراير,2024 at 1:55 ص

    generic lipitor 20mg lipitor 80mg pill atorvastatin 80mg tablet

  46. Otkuji

    24 فبراير,2024 at 2:11 ص

    buy amlodipine 10mg online cheap norvasc without prescription norvasc drug

  47. Zhrvwn

    24 فبراير,2024 at 6:39 م

    buy acyclovir cheap cost zovirax 400mg purchase zyloprim online cheap

  48. Cgmhlo

    25 فبراير,2024 at 10:46 ص

    buy lisinopril generic order lisinopril 5mg sale order generic lisinopril

  49. Istgtp

    26 فبراير,2024 at 1:49 ص

    crestor 10mg uk where can i buy crestor ezetimibe for sale online

  50. Aypmde

    27 فبراير,2024 at 7:31 ص

    order generic domperidone 10mg motilium us buy generic sumycin

  51. Tynqvv

    28 فبراير,2024 at 4:21 ص

    where can i buy metoprolol metoprolol 50mg sale metoprolol order online

  52. Wnboby

    28 فبراير,2024 at 5:53 م

    order cyclobenzaprine 15mg online baclofen brand order ozobax for sale

  53. Vlmxba

    1 مارس,2024 at 10:50 م

    where can i buy methylprednisolone methylprednisolone 16 mg otc medrol online

  54. Rsrirr

    2 مارس,2024 at 2:36 ص

    how to buy ketorolac toradol sale buy colcrys generic

  55. Gqyxfk

    3 مارس,2024 at 5:49 ص

    write essays for money term paper service buy a term paper online

  56. Jasget

    3 مارس,2024 at 2:28 م

    inderal 20mg tablet plavix canada order plavix 75mg pills

  57. Gbmwwy

    4 مارس,2024 at 6:00 م

    cost methotrexate order methotrexate 10mg generic where to buy coumadin without a prescription

  58. Mwmzgq

    5 مارس,2024 at 3:05 ص

    buy mobic 7.5mg online celebrex sale buy celebrex pills for sale

  59. 네이버 아이디 구매

    5 مارس,2024 at 8:31 ص

    저희는 구글 계정 판매 전문 회사입니다.우리의 구글 계정은 이메일, 문서, 캘리더, 클라우드 저장 등의 기능을 포함한 포괄적인 디지털 솔루션을 제공합니다.구글 계정을 통해 우리는 사용자에게 효율적인 협업 플랫품을 제공하여 개인과 팀이 일과 삶을 더 스마트하게 관리할 수 있도록 지원합니다.

  60. Qnbwad

    5 مارس,2024 at 9:15 م

    brand metoclopramide 20mg reglan order buy cozaar 25mg online

  61. 비아그라 온라인

    6 مارس,2024 at 9:07 ص

    비아그라를 구매하려면 알레르기 반응을 고려해야 합니다. 비아그라 주요 성분에 알레르기가 있을 수 있으므로, 의사와 상의하고 알레르기 반응 증상을 주시해야 합니다

  62. Zjrjjp

    6 مارس,2024 at 2:42 م

    order tamsulosin 0.4mg generic flomax online order where to buy celecoxib without a prescription

  63. Aavtwy

    9 مارس,2024 at 1:29 ص

    order nexium 40mg nexium 20mg cheap buy topiramate 100mg sale

  64. Lxkecu

    9 مارس,2024 at 11:05 ص

    order zofran 4mg generic purchase spironolactone buy spironolactone without a prescription

  65. Ufrobo

    10 مارس,2024 at 5:34 ص

    purchase sumatriptan pill imitrex canada order levofloxacin 500mg generic

  66. Ypgsbq

    10 مارس,2024 at 7:18 م

    order simvastatin 10mg sale buy valtrex 500mg online purchase valtrex generic

  67. 네이버 아이디 판매

    11 مارس,2024 at 10:21 ص

    저희는 구글 계정 판매 전문 회사입니다.우리의 구글 계정은 이메일, 문서, 캘리더, 클라우드 저장 등의 기능을 포함한 포괄적인 디지털 솔루션을 제공합니다.구글 계정을 통해 우리는 사용자에게 효율적인 협업 플랫품을 제공하여 개인과 팀이 일과 삶을 더 스마트하게 관리할 수 있도록 지원합니다.

  68. Epewqa

    11 مارس,2024 at 4:38 م

    how to get dutasteride without a prescription buy zantac 300mg generic buy ranitidine 150mg

  69. Qgowra

    13 مارس,2024 at 4:05 ص

    order finasteride 5mg generic order finasteride without prescription order diflucan 200mg for sale

  70. Hmvktk

    13 مارس,2024 at 5:38 ص

    order ampicillin pills amoxicillin buy online buy amoxil tablets

  71. 네이버 아이디 구매

    14 مارس,2024 at 4:19 ص

    네이버 플랫품에서 사용되는 아이디를 판매하고 있습니다. 네이버 아이디 판매 가격은 1,000원이고 30개부터 구매 가능합니다.

  72. Krpzjb

    14 مارس,2024 at 12:30 م

    ciprofloxacin 500mg pill – buy bactrim 960mg without prescription amoxiclav uk

  73. Gbdyzp

    15 مارس,2024 at 8:32 ص

    cipro 500mg without prescription – cheap augmentin 1000mg buy amoxiclav for sale

  74. Pcbcsg

    17 مارس,2024 at 8:15 ص

    buy metronidazole online cheap – order amoxil zithromax for sale online

  75. 시알리스 구매

    18 مارس,2024 at 6:02 م

    비아그라 100mg 1+1  2판(8정) 9,9000원  비아그라는 Prizer라는 제약회사에서 생산하는 발기 부전 치료제로,실데나필이라는 주요 성분을 포함하고 있습니다. 이 약물은 혈관을 확장시켜 성기에 더 많은 혈액을 유입시ㅣ켜 발기를 도와주는 효과를 가지고 있습니다.

  76. Dwftef

    18 مارس,2024 at 7:19 م

    how to get ciprofloxacin without a prescription – doxycycline tablet order erythromycin 250mg pill

  77. 네이버 아이디 구매

    19 مارس,2024 at 4:08 ص

    네이버 최고급 프리미업 아이디 판매, 네이버 아이디 구매사이트,네이버 비실명계정 구매사이트.

  78. Hufigt

    19 مارس,2024 at 1:07 م

    buy generic valacyclovir – how to buy valtrex generic acyclovir

  79. Kllxvj

    20 مارس,2024 at 10:44 م

    buy ivermectin 3 mg – sumycin where to buy buy generic sumycin online

  80. Rjcgdg

    21 مارس,2024 at 4:13 م

    order flagyl 400mg for sale – azithromycin drug buy generic azithromycin 500mg

  81. Wvlyva

    23 مارس,2024 at 12:58 ص

    buy acillin generic amoxil price amoxicillin over the counter

  82. Xyllsq

    23 مارس,2024 at 6:12 ص

    buy lasix 100mg pills – oral prograf order captopril 25 mg for sale

  83. 비아그라 온라인 구매

    25 مارس,2024 at 8:31 ص

    100%정품비아그라,약국에서 판매되는 제품과 동일한 제품만 취급합니다.

  84. Madgxq

    26 مارس,2024 at 12:06 م

    buy zidovudine pill – order avalide online cheap zyloprim without prescription

  85. Bkvmee

    26 مارس,2024 at 5:52 م

    purchase glycomet sale – buy bactrim online how to get lincocin without a prescription

Leave a Reply

لن يتم نشر عنوان بريدك الإلكتروني. الحقول الإلزامية مشار إليها بـ *

To Top